Type to search

After State Takes Child, Kansas Woman Is At Center Of National Marijuana Debate

Health National News Top News

After State Takes Child, Kansas Woman Is At Center Of National Marijuana Debate


By Donald Bradley, The Kansas City Star (TNS)

KANSAS CITY, Mo. — Shona Banda says she had a clear choice: Live in misery or use medical marijuana to ease her Crohn’s disease and risk going to jail.

Turned out to be an easy call for the Garden City, Kan., woman. She said her symptoms eased to the point where she could return to work and once again play with her young son.

But she didn’t count on that same son, now 11, speaking out in school recently about the benefits of medical marijuana, including saying that it had saved his mother’s life. School officials contacted police, who searched her house and found marijuana and cannabis oil.

That’s where her old choice took a new turn. Police didn’t take her to jail. Authorities took her son away and put him in protective state custody.

A month ago, Banda, 37, was a massage therapist eking out a living in the back room of a health food store.

Today, her story has gone global. More than 84,000 people have signed an online petition supporting her. Signatures have come from across the country as well as Spain, France, India, Austria, Sweden, Switzerland, Singapore, Slovenia, Russiam and the United Arab Emirates.

As prosecutors in Finney County consider charges against Banda, a GoFundMe account has produced nearly $40,000 in donations for her possible legal fight.

Part of the outrage is that had she lived an hour to the west, in Colorado, she would have been perfectly fine having marijuana in the house.

“Them taking her son made Shona the perfect storm,” said Sarah Swain, Banda’s attorney.

Even conservative radio commentator Glenn Beck chimed in, criticizing the “smugness” of the police officers who responded to Banda’s house and even questioning the merit of prosecuting marijuana cases.

Hold on, says Eric Voth, a Topeka physician and longtime marijuana opponent.

“Until all the reports are in, I would urge people to take pause,” Voth said. “I can’t presume to know what happened in this case. I know a lot of people are trying to voice compassion, but when police and child agencies take a kid out of a home, they do so with serious consideration.”

Voth says marijuana has serious toxic and long-term effects, and causes domestic and spousal violence.

Lisa Sublett, who heads the patient advocacy group Bleeding Kansas, thinks charges against Banda could lead to a case that changes Kansas law, perhaps even going to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Sounds expensive for a Garden City single mom and massage therapist.

“I think the cannabis movement will make sure she has the money,” Sublett said.

On March 24, Banda arrived home and found two Garden City police officers and two child social workers on her porch. Two more officers were elsewhere on her property.

Banda recorded with her cellphone as she approached the group.

“What are you doing?” she asked the officers. “Why are you on my porch and in my backyard?”

“We got a call from the Department for Children and Families and we need to speak with you,” a female officer said. “Will you give us consent to search your home?”

“No,” Banda answered. She again asked why officers were in her backyard.

“We have a right to be where the public has a right to be,” the female officer said.

“The public does not have a right to be in my backyard,” Banda said.

Police eventually got a warrant, and their search of the house turned up marijuana. They referred the case to the Finney County attorney for possible charges of possession of marijuana with intent to distribute, possession of drug paraphernalia and child endangerment.

Finney County Attorney Susan H. Richmeier did not return a call seeking comment.

Banda said she started using medical marijuana about five years ago for Crohn’s disease, an inflammatory bowel disease that causes abdominal pain, severe diarrhea, fatigue, weight loss, and malnutrition. The condition can lead to life-threatening complications.

Before starting with the marijuana, she said, she walked with a cane and often couldn’t get off the couch.

Banda does not say marijuana can help everyone, but in her case the pain greatly diminished, allowing her to return to work and ride bikes with her son.

“Sure, I talked to him about it (marijuana),” Banda said.

Authorities talked to the boy after the incident at school. Swain says they interrogated the fifth-grader without parental consent, which she contends is unconstitutional.

“They talked to him for more than an hour,” Banda said.

There’s no question that public sentiment toward marijuana has changed greatly in recent years.

Voters in Colorado, Oregon, Washington, Alaska, and the District of Columbia approved recreational marijuana. Another 20 or so states have medical marijuana.

More states, including California, are expected to put issues on the ballot this year.

Also, many health and medical organizations, such as the American College of Physicians and the American Medical Association, have softened views on marijuana and called for more research. A derivative called “Charlotte’s Web” is increasingly being used for child seizure disorder.

The Epilepsy Foundation “supports the rights of patients and families living with seizures and epilepsy to access physician directed care, including medical marijuana.”

But the federal government still lists marijuana as a Schedule 1 drug, the same as heroin and LSD. The designation means it has no medical benefit and a high potential for abuse.

President Barack Obama recently voiced support for medical marijuana. And, according to the Pew Institute, 53 percent of Americans now favor medical marijuana.

Sublett said, the Banda case would almost be funny if it was not so traumatizing to a family.

“The question to Kansans is, ‘Are you OK with your tax dollars being spent on this?'” Sublett said. “This woman goes to bed at night without her son because she had some marijuana in her house when it’s legal in half the country — are you OK with that?”

Voth rejects all the recent developments as misguided. He says the push for legal pot overlooks health risks in favor of money. Medical marijuana has not been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

“The public has been heavily manipulated into approving these measures,” Voth said. “I’m very worried about the real science being overlooked.”

For now, Banda waits for news from Finney County. She said her business is off because people are afraid to come for a massage. Especially, she said, after two men barged in one day and quickly left.

“I had an 80-year-old naked Mennonite woman on the table,” Banda said. “She could have had a heart attack.”

Banda and Swain do not know who the men were.

Swain, of Lawrence, said life is tough right now on Banda.

“She’s giving her life to this and we’re going to fight this until we win,” she said.

For Banda, happiness won’t come with winning a court case.

“I’ll be happy when I get my son back,” she said.

(c)2015 The Kansas City Star (Kansas City, Mo.), Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Photo: Shona Banda is a mother from Garden City, Kan., who has been thrust into the national spotlight in the country’s debate over marijuana, on April 27, 2015. Already an activist because medical marijuana treatment for her Crohn’s Disease, Banda’s 11-year-old son was taken by state authorities after he made comments at school about the health benefits of marijuana. (Shane Keyser/Kansas City Star/TNS)



  1. Daniel Jones May 2, 2015

    MISTER Voth:

    “Reefer Madness” is not real science. And political hacks are not real scientists. Hell, half of you parasitic jerks aren’t even political scientists–a discipline with as much scientific validity as, say, Christian Scientist teachings.

  2. Johnny Z May 2, 2015

    This is no different from kid napping to me. Funny how these anti-Marijuana bigots never even think of taking kids from parents that use alcohol or even abuse alcohol. This BS needs to stop. That Voth idiot needs a good punch in the mouth for lying out his arse. Damned creep!

  3. charleo1 May 2, 2015

    More from the small gov. spouting, incarceration first, RWNJs that have highjacked,
    and nearly bankrupted the State of KS. Now, a virtual bureaucratic hellhole of wealth worshipping, abortion obsessed, marriage equality hating, Puritans. That have no fundamental belief at all, in the merits of what it means to live in a democracy.

  4. Bruce Ackman May 2, 2015

    The FDA cannot approve medical marijuana because the federal government has forbidden research into the medical benefits of marijuna.

  5. Rippie May 2, 2015

    This is a rare instance in which I agree with Glenn Beck’s “WTF??” stance on this case.

    Instead of fighting to stay in such a hateful and non-inclusive state as KS, Banda’s GoFundMe page should be altered to apply the funds to get her the hell OUT of KS and into a state that will not have a problem with her palliative use of marijuana. Somewhere with more rainfall and cooler weather would probably be nice, too.

    The mountainous examples of intolerance and outright ignorant hate that come out of KS over the years make choosing the fight and choosing the solutions a bit more textured than simply insisting on staying put.

    Other states have FAR more compassionate laws about marijuana, particularly for pain or nausea patients, even if casual use is still not decriminalized.

    Choosing what form of suffering to endure, and upon whom it’s inflicted is a typical neocon rightwing “fix” for everything. Of course, if anyone does or acts differently than they think things should be done, it’s a big deal.

    As far as the increasing number of states with medical marijuana availability and/or easing of criminal casual use laws, at least for now, the Feds have been told to back off and not enforce simple possession or most medical distribution facilities. The issue of handling the actual cash and how to more effectively collect taxes from a business that is being blocked from using classic banking is being addressed with various ideas.

    If the Federal laws defining marijuana as a dangerous substance were changed, it would probably be possible to fight KS based purely on the Supremacy Clause.

    For now, Banda is unable to do that and people in KS are notoriously famous for being massive buttinskys into the most private aspects of the lives of others… like typical Republican’t-stand-truthers do everywhere.

    Given the current set of conditions, it makes the most sense to use her money to move out of the state so that KS cannot have any jurisdiction over how she lives with her child, and they will have to back down.

    Amazing, considering that we could never have been successful in the end with our Revolution without hemp, THE critical strategic, as well as major cash crop of the early America.

    Now it’s the Devil’s Weed. Unbelievable. Truth is stranger than fiction.

  6. toptwome May 2, 2015

    A child is always better off with their mother and father. This just shows the GOP are crazy in Kansas. This woman needs the marijuana because of her cancer. But there is no sense with the right wing crazy thugs.

  7. dana becker May 4, 2015

    “Voth says marijuana has serious toxic and long-term effects, and causes domestic and spousal violence.”

    Bull. Alcohol does that.

    Bet Kansas would let her buy guns all day long and keep them out for her kid to get a hold of because that sure doesn’t endanger them right?


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.